Home care

Home Care Against the Price of a Nursing Home

Save

Most families ask this question with a facility brochure in one hand and no idea what the other side costs. The national benchmark for a home health aide is built on 44 hours a week, a fraction of the 168 a facility covers. Here is what each price includes, what Medicare and Medicaid will and will not pay toward either, and how to run the arithmetic on your own household's hours.

Last updated: July 2026History

Talk to a clinician

Gale can help you find a clinician in your state and request a visit.

Find care →

Two prices, two different shapes

The two numbers are not comparable as written, and that is how most families get this wrong. Home care is sold by the hour, so the bill tracks the need — twelve hours of help costs twice what six hours costs. A nursing home is sold by the day, and the day is a bundle: the room, the meals, the laundry, and staff on the premises for all twenty-four hours whether or not anyone rings a call bell.

One of those prices moves with need. The other does not. So the useful question is never "which is cheaper." It is "at how many hours does the moving one pass the fixed one."

The home side has a national benchmark worth quoting. The 2024 Cost of Care Survey put the median annual cost of a home health aide at $77,792, and homemaker services at $75,504 1. Those are consumer prices — what an agency charges a family, not what the aide earns.

The facility side has no number this page can responsibly hand you. A nursing home quotes a rate per building, and the only figure that matters to your household is the one printed on the admission agreement in front of you. A national median would give you the comfort of a number without the use of one. So this page prices the home side precisely, then gives you the arithmetic to hold a real facility quote against it.

What $77,792 a year actually buys

It buys 44 hours a week. That is the assumption underneath the national median: 44 hours a week, 52 weeks a year 1. There are 168 hours in a week. So the benchmark everyone quotes covers roughly a quarter of the time, and the other three-quarters are still yours — or a family member's, or nobody's.

That assumption is the most important and least noticed thing about the figure. Work it backwards and the annual number turns into something you can actually use. Forty-four hours across 52 weeks is 2,288 hours of care. The aide median divides out to exactly $34.00 for one of them; homemaker help, to exactly $33.00 1.

The national annual medians are an hourly rate in disguise — about $34 an hour for a home health aide, $33 for homemaker services 1.

Once you have the rate, the year becomes multiplication:

Hours of care each weekAt $34 an hourWhat that looks like
20$35,360 a yearmornings, five days a week
44$77,792 a yearthe survey's benchmark — about six hours a day
84$148,512 a yeartwelve hours a day, every day
168$297,024 a yearround-the-clock hourly shifts

Only the 44-hour row is a survey finding. The others are that row's own hourly rate multiplied out, and they are printed here because the line they draw is the entire point: home care has no ceiling. It rises until it passes anything.

The hours at which that rising line crosses a facility's flat one are what people mean by home care break-even hours. There is no national answer, because the facility's line is different in every building and the aide's rate is different in every market. But the shape is universal, and the shape is what most families are missing when they start.

Does Medicare pay for any of this?

Not for the hours. Original Medicare's home health benefit is real, and it is free at the point of use — you pay $0 for covered home health services, and 20% for durable medical equipment 2. But what it buys is medical and it is short: part-time or intermittent skilled nursing, physical, occupational and speech therapy, medical social services, and a home health aide only alongside skilled care 2.

The exclusions are what answer this page's question. The benefit explicitly does not cover 24-hour-a-day care at home. It does not cover meals delivered to the house. And it does not cover custodial or personal care when that is the only care needed 2.

Read that last clause twice. The help you are trying to price — someone to get your mother safely out of the bath, someone in the house at four in the afternoon — is custodial care. Custodial care by itself is the one thing the benefit names as excluded 2.

Custodial care is help with the ordinary business of having a body: bathing, dressing, toileting, eating, getting from bed to chair. Nothing about it is medical, and that line — skilled versus custodial care — is the hinge every coverage decision on this page turns on.

This is the most expensive misunderstanding in long-term care planning, and it is an honest one. Families read that Medicare covers home health, reasonably conclude the hours are handled, and discover otherwise in the week they can least afford the surprise. The benefit is genuinely valuable for what it is — a nurse after a hospital stay, a therapist after a hip — but it was never built to staff a household. Before planning around it, it is worth reading what the intermittent skilled care requirement actually demands and what the covered home health services actually are, because both are narrower than the name suggests.

Medicaid is the payer that usually decides this

For most families who genuinely have to choose, Medicaid decides it. Medicaid pays for nearly 70% of all home care spending in the United States, and an estimated 5.1 million enrollees use home care through it 3. But there is a structural asymmetry inside that number: Medicaid's home care is, in most states, an optional benefit, frequently delivered through a capped waiver rather than an open entitlement 3.

Capped means a line. In 2025, 41 states kept a waiting or interest list for home- and community-based services. Roughly 700,000 people were on one. The average wait for waiver services ran about 32 months 4.

The average wait for Medicaid waiver services in 2025 was about 32 months — 41 states kept a list, and roughly 700,000 people were on one 4.

Nearly three years. Hold that against the table above and you can see what actually settles this question for a great many households. It is not the arithmetic. It is whether the money exists on the day the help is needed. A waiver that arrives in 2029 does not pay for a bath in 2026.

This is worth saying plainly, because families carry a lot of guilt about it: if your parent went to a facility, it very often was not a failure of planning or of love. It was that one door had a queue in front of it and the other door was open that week.

And because these are state-run programs, the queue is a fact about your state rather than about the country — 41 states had a list, which means the number that matters to you is your own state's, not the national average 4. That is the first call to make, and it is worth making it long before anyone needs a bath they cannot manage.

Not every hour needs a $34 aide

Home care is not one product, and paying for the top rung across the whole week is an easy way to overpay. The National Institute on Aging lays out the rungs: companion and check-in services, often run by volunteers and often at no cost; homemaker and household chore help; personal care — bathing, dressing, grooming, toileting, eating, moving; and skilled home health from a licensed professional 5.

The obvious move is to match the task to the rung and pay less for the lighter hours. Here the survey delivers an unwelcome surprise: about two-thirds of home care agencies now charge the same rate whether the work is folding laundry or lifting someone out of a bathtub 1. Nationally, only $2,288 a year separates the two medians — which, across 2,288 hours, is a difference of one dollar an hour 1.

So downgrading the task saves you close to nothing at roughly two-thirds of agencies. It is worth asking any agency directly which side of that two-thirds it sits on, because at the other third it is real money.

Where the ladder does earn its keep is at the bottom, and this is the part families most often leave on the table. Companion and check-in services are frequently volunteer-run and free, and every hour one of them covers is an hour you do not buy at $34 5. Area Agencies on Aging are the front door for arranging any of it — homemaker help, personal care, the check-in visit 5. They are also the least-used resource in this entire field.

At the far end of the ladder the arithmetic changes completely. When the need is genuinely medical — a wound, a ventilator, an infusion — you are pricing private-duty nursing cost, not an aide's hour, and that is a different order of number. The distinction between medical vs non-medical care is what separates the two, and it is worth knowing which one you are actually shopping for before you call anyone.

Why the home-care price is not going to fall

Because it is almost entirely wages, and the wages are already low. Labor is the top cost driver in home care pricing 1, and the labor in question is not well compensated: the direct care workforce numbers about 5.4 million people, roughly 3.2 million of them in home care, with median earnings near $26,000 a year, many working part-time, and about half relying on public assistance of some kind 6.

Two facts sit awkwardly together, and both are true. You are billed a rate that works out to roughly $34 an hour 1. The person standing in your mother's kitchen works in an occupation whose median earnings are around $26,000 a year 6. Neither number has much give in it.

The gap between them is where the agency's own operation sits. What exactly it buys — screening, supervision, liability insurance, payroll taxes, a replacement when someone calls out at 6am — is a fair thing to ask any agency to itemize before signing. Some of it is real value that a family cannot easily reproduce alone. Some of it is overhead. The point is that the gap is not slack you can negotiate away by asking nicely.

That same workforce data predicts the thing families complain about most and quietly blame themselves for. Turnover is high and projected openings are enormous 6. The aide who knows that your father takes his tea with two sugars and will not admit he is cold — that person will, statistically, move on. It is usually not your agency failing you and it is not your father being difficult. It is a job paying near $26,000 a year 6 competing against every other job paying near $26,000 a year, most of which do not involve lifting a grown adult out of a bathtub at seven in the morning.

Home care is expensive because caregiving is labor, and it is hard to staff because that labor is underpaid. Both halves of that sentence are the same fact.

How to run the comparison for your own household

Three numbers decide it, and only one of them is on this page. First: the hours where someone must actually be present — not the hours you would like to buy, but the hours in which being alone is the problem. Second: your local hourly rate, which the national $34 only approximates 1. Third: the facility's real quoted rate, in writing, with its exclusions named out loud.

  • Count the hours honestly. The failure mode is counting the tasks instead. Bathing takes forty minutes; the reason someone needs to be there is the eleven hours around it. Count presence, not chores.
  • Get both rates locally. The national median describes the middle of a wide distribution 1. Your county sits somewhere on it, and possibly nowhere near the middle.
  • Multiply, then compare. Weekly hours times the local rate, times 52. That single line is the home side of the comparison, and it is the line most brochures are designed to keep you from drawing.
  • Ask the facility what its rate excludes. A quoted daily rate and the eventual monthly invoice are not always the same conversation. Ask what triggers a higher level of care, and what is billed on top.
  • Then add the line that appears on no invoice. Every home plan has an unpaid caregiver inside it. Their hours are free to the arithmetic and expensive to the person. When the two columns come out close, that unbilled labor is almost always what actually breaks the tie — and it is worth being honest about who is being volunteered, and whether they know.

Two situations bend this arithmetic enough to need their own numbers. Dementia changes what "present" means, which is why home care vs memory care cost runs on a different calculation than this one. And a skilled medical need moves you off the aide's rate entirely. Neither is a footnote to this page; each is its own page, because each is its own math.

Common questions

No. It is cheaper at low hours and more expensive at high hours, because home care is billed by the hour while a facility charges a flat daily rate that already includes the room, the food, and all twenty-four hours. The crossover point depends on your local aide rate and the specific facility's quote, so it is arithmetic rather than a rule.

The 2024 survey's median of $77,792 a year for a home health aide is built on 44 hours a week across 52 weeks. That is 2,288 hours, which works out to exactly $34.00 an hour. Homemaker services divide out to $33.00. The annual headline is an hourly rate wearing a year's clothing, and the hourly rate is the more useful number.

Only alongside skilled care, and only part-time. Medicare's home health benefit covers intermittent skilled nursing and therapy at no cost to you, and an aide can come as part of that. But it explicitly does not cover 24-hour care at home, or custodial and personal care when help with bathing and dressing is the only thing needed. That is the care most families are trying to buy.

In many states, yes — Medicaid pays for nearly 70% of home care spending nationally. The catch is that home care is usually an optional benefit delivered through capped waivers, so states run waiting lists. In 2025, 41 states had one, roughly 700,000 people were waiting, and the average wait for waiver services was about 32 months.

About two-thirds of home care agencies now price both service types identically. Nationally the two medians differ by roughly a dollar an hour. Practically, that means asking for a cheaper aide to do lighter work often saves nothing. It is still worth asking a specific agency how it prices the two, since about a third do still charge differently.

Both are true at once. Families are billed roughly $34 an hour while home care workers have median earnings near $26,000 a year, with about half relying on some public assistance. The difference covers the agency's screening, supervision, insurance, payroll taxes, and backup coverage. It is reasonable to ask any agency to itemize that gap before signing.

Related

Say it back

How would you explain this to someone you love?

Two or three sentences, just as you’d say it. Gale reflects back what you focused on — a mirror, not a quiz.

Talk to a clinician

Gale can help you find a clinician in your state and request a visit.

Find care →

When the hours you bought are no longer enough

  • —Reddened skin over the tailbone, hips, or heels that does not blanch when you press it, or any open sore — a sign that repositioning is not happening in the hours between visits
  • —A fall nobody witnessed, or one your parent cannot recall, especially in someone taking a blood thinner
  • —Pills left uncounted, doubled up, or untouched in the box between aide visits
  • —Weight loss alongside untouched meals or an unopened fridge — the hours are not covering eating

A fall with a head strike, a fall in someone taking a blood thinner, or any new confusion, vomiting, or difficulty waking after a fall belongs in an emergency department the same day rather than in a Monday phone call. Call 911 if they cannot be roused, are confused, or are vomiting.

Gale's health library explains how care is priced and paid for. It cannot price your parent's care or decide where they should live. The figures here are 2024 national medians describing the middle of a very wide distribution, and your market's numbers may sit well above or below them. Decisions about a care setting belong with your family, your parent's clinicians, and where the money is concerned, someone who can look at your actual numbers.

Did this answer your question?

References

  1. 1.Genworth Financial / CareScout (2025). Genworth and CareScout Release Cost of Care Survey Results for 2024. Genworth Financial (investor press release). link ✓The 2024 national median consumer cost of in-home care — $77,792/year for a home health aide and $75,504/year for homemaker services, both computed on 44 hours a week for 52 weeks — the hourly rates implied by that stated basis, the finding that about two-thirds of home care agencies now charge the same rate for both service types, and that labor is the top cost driver.
  2. 2.Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (2025). Home Health Services Coverage. Medicare.gov. link ✓What Original Medicare's home health benefit covers — part-time or intermittent skilled nursing, physical, occupational and speech therapy, medical social services, and a part-time home health aide only alongside skilled care, at $0 to the patient for covered services and 20% for durable medical equipment — and what it explicitly excludes: 24-hour-a-day care at home, delivered meals, and custodial or personal care when that is the only care needed.
  3. 3.KFF (Kaiser Family Foundation) (2025). Medicaid Home Care (HCBS) in 2025. KFF. link ✓That Medicaid pays for nearly 70% of U.S. home care spending, that an estimated 5.1 million Medicaid enrollees use home care, and that home care is most often an optional benefit delivered through capped waivers rather than an open entitlement.
  4. 4.KFF (Kaiser Family Foundation) (2025). A Look at Waiting Lists for Medicaid Home- and Community-Based Services from 2016 to 2025. KFF. link ✓That 41 states kept HCBS waiting or interest lists in 2025, that roughly 0.7 million people were on such a list, and that the average wait for waiver services was about 32 months.
  5. 5.National Institute on Aging (NIH) (2025). Services for Older Adults Living at Home. National Institute on Aging, NIH. link ✓The taxonomy of in-home support — companion and check-in services (often volunteer and at no cost), homemaker and household chore help, personal care with bathing, dressing, grooming, toileting, eating and mobility, and skilled home health services — and that Area Agencies on Aging are how a family arranges them.
  6. 6.PHI (Paraprofessional Healthcare Institute) (2025). Direct Care Workers in the United States: Key Facts 2025. PHI (phinational.org). link ✓Direct-care workforce scale and economics — roughly 5.4 million direct care workers including about 3.2 million home care workers, median earnings near $26,000 a year, many working part-time, about half relying on public assistance, and high turnover alongside large projected job openings.

6 sources, numbered by first appearance. General health information, not medical advice. AI-assisted editorial content — every citation independently verified. Editorial policy

← Back to the health library